Jose Luis Castillo vs. Rolando Reyes

Boxers

Castillo name Reyes 53-7-1 (47) W-L-D (ko's) 26-3-2 (16) 32 Age 27 5'8" Height 5'10" 138 lbs 138 69" Reach 72"

Knowledge of Fighters: I watched both Corrales vs Castillo fights. No knowledge of Reyes

Prefight Bias:I was pulling for Corrales in both fights. I have nothing against Castillo. I feel very neutral about these fighters.

Watched: Taped. Watched first 5 that nite and the rest the next morning

Ref: Lawrence Cole

Judges:

Ray Hawkins (Dalas, TX) 116-111
Jesse Reyes (Plano, TX) 117-110
Gale Van Hoy (Dickinson, TX) 119-108

Press and Commentator Scores

Showtime commentator (Al Bernstein ?) 118-109
Matt Aguilar 117-110
Roberto Carrillo 116-116 with three 10-10 rounds
Ricardo Trujillo 116-112

My Card

Name	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	10	11	12	Total
Castillo	10	10	10	9	10	10	9	10	10	10	10	10	118
Reyes	9	9	9	10	9	9	9	9	9	9	9	9	109

Notes:

Round #7: 1 point taken from Castillo for a low blow (3rd of fight)

Round #8: Castillo won the round but didn't do to much. Reyes landed two clean punches at the end of the round and I bet some of press row and perhaps other judges gave Reyes the round for that. I can't ignore that Castillo dominated the other 2:50 in the round and landed more punches in the round... came forward and dictated the fight.

Round #9: BORING... lost a bit of interest so if Reyes did something that made him deserve the round I missed it. I gave the round to Castillo because he was the agressor... I probably should have scored this 10-10.